It's weird how memories come back. I hear people talking about memories being triggered by a sight or a smell or song and coming rushing back. Yes, that can happen, but for the past week or so, I’ve been experiencing a trickle--an extremely frustrating, bordering on non-existent trickle. Oh that it would be a flood and be over with!
A couple weeks ago, I stumbled upon a hand-drawn rock band poster a musician named Scott gave me about three decades ago. He told me to hang on to it because when his band became famous, it would be worth a lot of money. I've kept it all these years in a scrapbook--not because I necessarily believed he would make it big and the poster would be valuable but rather because I promised, and because he held a special place in a young girl’s heart--the young girl who became me. When I found this poster, I wondered if Scott’s band ever achieved some level of success... then I realized that in this day and age of technology, there was no need to wonder.
Enter Google. I googled the name of Scott’s band, along with his name, the instrument he played and the state he lived in when I knew him... and low and behold... the top result was a youtube video--a different band, but Scott was the lead singer and keyboardist. Under the video, there was information about the concert venue that Scott now runs, complete with a link to the website.
Perusing the guidelines for submissions of bands interested in performing there, I discovered that Scott himself was the one in charge of it all. Hmmm, wouldn’t it be fun to “submit” his own decades’ old band for consideration? I thought how crazy it would be if someone sent me a long lost piece of my childhood or adolescent writing out of the blue to be “considered for production.” What a hoot that would be!
So, I snapped a picture of the poster, and sent it off with an email saying I thought this band would be perfect for his venue. I figured that given his stint with regional fame, and the accompanying groupies, he probably wouldn’t remember me, so I simply said that: “I don’t expect you to remember me--It’s been a L O N G time. I hope you are doing well and that you enjoy this poster.”
At that point in time, I was having trouble scaring up many memories of him myself--and he definitely held a more significant place in my life than I did in his:
Scott was the administrator of my first real kiss. We were 14-15 years old, and I know I didn’t want to make it to “Sweet Sixteen” without being kissed. I think he kissed me within a week of my fifteenth birthday. Other than that, I was drawing a blank on our short, shallow “relationship” (if you can even call it that.)
Right after our brief stint (or actually in the midst of it), I met the guy who became my high school sweetheart, so I basically let the thing with Scott fizzle out--which wasn’t hard to do since he lived in a different town and neither one of us had a driver’s license yet.
I didn’t expect to hear back much more than, “Thank you, I’ll add it to all the other sketches my former fans have sent me”--if even that. But a reply did come. Scott was amused by the poster and the “delusional dreams” of his adolescence that it exhibited, but that wasn’t all he had to say. After exchanging a few niceties about seeing that what I was doing (via google and imdb) was great, he went on to add something more personal:
“Well, I DO remember you sending me a letter calling me the spawn of Satan or something about burning in hell.”
I read those words in disbelief. I didn’t even remember writing to him at all, let alone ever saying anything so harsh.
I replied: “WHAT??? Not seriously? I'd like to see that, 'cuz I sure don't remember anything like it.” Recalling that I had basically dumped him for another guy, I went on to say that maybe I didn't treat him fairly and that I may not have been honest with him then because I was confused myself and wasn’t being totally honest with myself. “Did I really say horrible things in a letter, though???” I asked. His recollection sounded so out of character for me.
Since sending off that reply, I’ve been wracking my brain trying to remember. I'm just waking up to the fact that I may have actually hurt him... It really had never dawned on me that I was anything more to him than a fleeting fling, but now that one of my sons is just a year younger than Scott was--and just starting to take an interest in girls--I'm thinking how easy it would be for some girl to just crush him. Awww, Scott was some mommy's little boy, too... Did I really write something to him that he interpreted as meaning that I thought he was the spawn of Satan? And since I now have a faith that I didn’t have then, it’s really bugging me that whatever hurt I may have dealt out was tinged with any religious overtones that may have been interpreted as “Christianity.” I know that I wasn’t a Christian then, but he doesn’t know that.
As the day went by, since reading his note, my memory has been stirred a bit more, and another trickle has seeped out. Now, I do remember writing him a “break up” letter, but I don’t remember what I said. I remember deliberating over the wording, and yet the words I settled on now completely elude me. The memory is almost like I’m watching a silent movie... a fifteen-year-old girl, whom I barely recognize sits at the kitchen table... no, on the living room couch... no, on her bed... actually, I do see myself working on the letter long enough that I am carrying it from one location to another. I may have even spoken with my mother about it. I’m kind of wondering if Scott had called me about getting together and that was what prompted the letter. Is it strange for a memory like that to be so incredibly foggy?
I know many of you would say, “Drop it! Forget about it! You were just kids--it’s really no big deal.” I’m sure Scott is over it, and if I was really so bitchy, maybe I even gave him some material for an angry song or two. So, once again, why do I keep digging back into the past???
Well, there’s the curiosity factor that just comes with the territory of being a writer and wanting to understand motivations and character arcs.
But then, there’s also the parallel I’m seeing between Scott back then and my son who is practically the same age now as Scott was when he received the allegedly awful letter. I never thought of Scott as fragile and tender back then, but that is what I see when I look at my son of the same age. Still, that’s not enough reason to stew over what exactly I did say in that letter. That’s more reason to just have some heart-to-heart discussions with my son about girls and relationships.
The main reason I think I’m feeling tormented over this is the fact that I think I may know part of the reason for the fogginess, and that reason has more to do with my own character. What if I’m blocking it out of my memory because I know that I lied? As I look back, I really find it hard to believe that I came right out and told Scott about the other guy, and if I didn’t tell him that, then what reason did I give him for suddenly not wanting to go out with him? I really, truly hope I didn’t use a judgmental God argument--a hypocritical excuse.
When I consider how crippled I still feel by some of the rejection of my youth from even before I met Scott, and how I’m still working through issues rooted deep in my childhood, I cannot ignore the possibility that any religious jargon I may have used in my letter to Scott way back then could have poisoned his view of the Christian faith to this day.
This is not a blog entry with any neatly wrapped-up resolution. I hope that I will remember more if there is anything I can learn from it (and, if there’s anything that I can use in my writing to lend authenticity to young characters and situations, and thus help another generation). And I pray that if there was hurt that turned to bitterness or that is in anyway still affecting Scott, that this silly little encounter over the poster now would bring clarity (especially on a spiritual level) that nothing I said then should be taken as representative of Christianity.
This story may be out of order--a strange place to start, but it is another chapter in my memoirs. If my memory awakens, maybe I’ll be able to complete this chapter of early adolescent lit.
I don’t think I’ve covered any of my history prior to college in this blog yet, have I? My high school sweetheart really was sweet... perhaps a chapter on him would lighten the sometimes-heavy mood around here. If I can’t remember more about Scott, do you want to know about the guy who replaced him (and was shy enough and respectful enough that he kept me out of a heap of trouble for the remainder of my high school years)? This I do know: If I had stayed with Scott, I probably would have ended up pregnant before I was out of high school and I could be in a situation even worse than my struggles with Todd.
I have been following your blog for a while and it stuck me today, that you must enjoy feeling guilty. You seem to be building a case against yourself. You seem to be functioning from the belief that you are guilty, condemned to suffer for something you did in the past. Something you DID must be the reason you are a miserable in your marraige. Could a girl, just 15 years old really be so powerful as to convince a boy to reject Christianity in his future because you penned a string of words addressed to him? Or the fact that you feed into Todd's selfish temper tantrums because maybe you believe that is all you deserve. Do you deserve his abuse? Do you enjoy it? What do you enjoy? A God who would hold you accountable to something you wrote when you were 15?
ReplyDeleteHmmm, there is validity to the "thinking I don't deserve better" thing... that's actually part of what I'm trying to delve into in examining my past--and I'm finding the Scott episode "interesting" and I'm curious to understand it better because of where it sits in what is emerging as a pattern--a pattern that goes deep into my childhood... and I'm not saying that as an excuse (ie. the typical psychological blaming of the parents or anything like that), but more as plain old observation.
ReplyDeleteI guess I know what I said in that letter probably doesn't amount to a heap of beans to Scott now [WAIT--I must be cautious about committing to that comment, because as I typed it just now, I realized that THAT is one of the unhealthy things I have done as long as I can remember--marginalized myself--discounting the possibility of my words, actions, even existence, having much of an impact on anyone (beyond my immediate family)...and I'm not saying that as an exercise in pity-partying, "look at me beat myself up and *enjoy* it" type thing, but rather in an attempt to be as honest as possible, because in my experience, true freedom doesn't come without true honesty.]
This is how I responded to moving around so much as a child, to coming into new communities (small towns) that were resistant to accepting "outsiders", and experiencing the discrimination against me because of what my dad did for a living (as a pastor)--which put a different set of expectations on me than other kids--and I was essentially never allowed to be a "normal" kid... I began to accept the "fact" that I didn't belong... it was sometimes easier just to be invisible--invisibility was preferable to being teased and laughed at. And since I was shy and my voice was weak, it wasn't too hard to be invisible. The people who really accepted me for who I was were few and far between, and since I wasn't a Christian--since I didn't have the acceptance of God--I was very much on my own. Life without God is sad--do people choose it because they *enjoy* being sad?--no, they chose it because they don't see things as they really are.
Do I believe God holds me accountable for what I wrote all those years ago??? Yes, and no. I guess it depends on what you mean by the word "accountable". According to His word, He absolutely does hold us accountable for every sin from the moment of our conception, but once we come to Him and trust in His payment for our sins, they are washed away as far as the need for payment goes--we are not to "beat ourselves up" over them. In that way, the account is settled.
Sometimes, however, people are hurt by our words and behaviors which we have been forgiven, but their pain still exists and is real, and when we pretend "it's all in the past", we're doing a disservice to the *opportunities* to make peace and to be ambassadors of peace. That, after all, is a constant complaint that is heard from unbelievers--they see believers who have done horrible things come to the Lord accept his forgiveness and then go on their merry way as if the trespass never occurred. In God's eyes, it never occurred--as in the believer will not be condemned for it, but that doesn't mean He would have us ignore the very real repercussions of it in the lives of people He desperately wants to bring healing to as well. (Hebrews 12:14: "Make every effort to live in peace with all men and to be holy; without holiness no one will see the Lord.")
The "let it go" philosophy while applying well to our grudges toward others, should not be applied to our efforts to make peace for our own offenses UNTIL WE HAVE ACTUALLY TRIED (Emphasis because I do acknowledge that once we have sincerely made that effort and that effort has been rejected, we are released to "let it go", but we need to put the effort and the release in the proper order if we are to be peacemakers.)
This Scott situation is perhaps a silly, trivial little example of this principle. He probably wasn't greatly affected by my words in the long run, but the emphasis on the word DO (as in him capitalizing it when he wrote "I DO remember...") alerted me to the fact that it is *possible* that he was. (It's hard to interpret tone of voice in email). I don't see that as a "beat myself up for it" type of revelation so much as a positive opportunity to make peace. I welcome that. And yes, I do *enjoy* opportunities to make peace--I believe such exercises draw us closer to God, and have the potential to draw others closer to God, too.
ReplyDeleteAs for Todd, I do see the effect of my attempts at peacemaking. Like another anonymous commenter said about how when she left her husband he noticed the "light" had left and he couldn't stand the darkness an begged her to come back. I may have not left Todd physically, but as I withdraw emotionally every time he treats me in a way I know I don't deserve, I believe he is noticing, and I believe he is trying to change. Do I *enjoy* staying? No, most certainly not. In many ways it would be easier to just leave and start my life from scratch. But what I do enjoy is the way every time I believe God bids me to be patient just a little bit longer, HE IS FAITHFUL to bless me for it. He is able to restore my hope when hope doesn't make sense. I don't believe I deserve abuse, but I do see that it is possible to stay and not be harmed by the emotional abuse--if that is what God bids me to do, He will also protect and heal my emotions as I draw closer to Him no matter where I am physically.
I may not sound very strong on this blog, as it is often at the lowest points that I'm most compelled to write, but I know I am getting stronger. What I am committed to now is not staying with Todd, but rather drawing closer to God. He will lead me. I don't pretend to know where He will lead me, but I know it will be good. Like the anonymous commenter said, it's going toward the Light.
In this blog, I'm trying to be honest about the bumps along the way. This is not an easy journey I'm going through, and I think some testimonies are misleading because they insist on having a black and white turning point: "My life was full of darkness, blah, blah, blah, then Jesus came and everything is perfectly rosy now!" They lead us to believe that is the template, and if we continue to struggle against encroaching darkness there is something wrong with our faith. If you ask me, that's trusting in a template, not a Person. I enjoy walking with that Person, Jesus.
So, back to the Scott situation... it's not about beating myself up. It's just that I believe that God is so big, and there is a reason when an opportunity like this presents itself. It may not be anything dramatic, or anything with huge impact, but God has given me an opportunity to clarify a misunderstanding. I think that's exciting. It may not be anything life changing for Scott (just like my words back then probably weren't life changing), but because I have the Spirit of the Living God in me Now, it is at least an opportunity to be that little whisper of God's love that may join the countless other ways God may be pursuing Scott and may make a difference not because of who I am or how clever my words are, but because I am a part of the body of Christ who refuses to let the words of my past speak condemnation and go unchallenged. It may be small, it may be trivial, but any efforts at peacemaking are at least good practice for the times that are most critical. I'm learning lessons from making peace with others that help me with making peace with Todd.
ReplyDeleteI really enjoy getting understanding. I've talked about the patterns. They're so easy to identify in others, but much more challenging to recognize in oneself. Even though it is sometimes embarrassing to acknowledge the patterns I discover in my own thought and behavior, it is freeing to finally see and no longer be condemned to the ruts they wear in life. The little I have been able to understand of the Scott episode looks almost like a seed of my later relationships. In understanding it, I think I will better be able to discern the patterns that followed.
I don't know if any of that makes sense to anyone else. This is like thinking out loud. The writer in me wants to go back and rewrite and edit to make sure I'm being clear, but the writer in me also has work to do on her paying job, so this for now remains rambling that probably makes just as little sense as my mind that is still groping for understanding.
If one thing is made clear here, I hope it is that not everything is about enjoyment. There are sometimes journeys that we have to go through to get to JOY. I don't think that those who take the short cut of brushy the yucky, painful and embarrassing things under the carpet and moving on really ever get to joy--happiness maybe, but happiness shadowed by the knowledge that there's still a bunch of gunk under the rug, happiness tempered by the ghosts in the closet. I don't have to enjoy everything I write about, everything I confess, but I guess you could say I enjoy getting it out--getting it out where it can be dealt with. It's like I don't "enjoy" throwing up when I'm sick because of something I ate--but I do enjoy the freedom that comes once the poison out of my system. It's a process.
Oopsy... Brushing, not brushy: "I don't think that those who take the short cut of BRUSHING the yucky, painful and embarrassing things under the carpet and moving on really ever get to joy..."
ReplyDelete